For people who aspire to lead international schools

Principal’s Blog

Whose Voice Shapes the Change? Leading with Mission Integrity Through Student Voice

by Rachel Cannon

A few years ago, when I was working at the American International School of Lagos (AISL), some students told us they didn’t feel represented by the Student Council.

I was one of the advisors at the time, and my first thought was, “Well, why didn’t they run for Student Council?”

I didn’t say it aloud, thankfully. But that’s what I thought.

We had a Student Council. Students could put themselves forward, attend meetings, share their ideas, and have a say in what was happening at school. If they wanted to be involved, the opportunity was there.

I was also a little surprised that they cared enough to bring it up. Not because I thought students didn’t care about their school, but because I hadn’t expected them to be paying such close attention to whether the Student Council was actually representing them.

The more I thought about their feedback, though, the more I realised I’d been looking at the situation from the wrong perspective.

These students weren’t asking to be on the Student Council. They were asking to be represented by it.

And when we looked more closely at how Student Council was operating, we realised that some of our representatives hadn’t quite understood that responsibility either.

We Had Given Them Leadership Positions

Some of our representatives didn’t really see gathering their classmates’ ideas as part of their job.

And I’ll admit, that frustrated me, too.

They’d been selected to represent their classmates. Surely they understood that meant listening to them?

But then I had another uncomfortable realization. Had we actually taught them how to do that?

We’d given them leadership positions, invited them to meetings, and expected them to contribute. But we hadn’t spent nearly enough time helping them understand what it meant to represent other people, particularly when those people had different ideas or priorities.

The funny thing is, we do this with adults in schools, too. We appoint teachers to middle leadership positions because they’re excellent educators, and then sometimes expect them to know how to lead a team. We assume they’ll be able to facilitate difficult conversations, bring different perspectives into decisions, and share responsibility with their colleagues. But those are skills that need to be developed.

Why was I expecting children to figure it out on their own?

Once we recognised that, our response became clearer. We needed to do more than explain the expectations. We needed to teach the students how to meet them.

As advisors, we introduced opportunities for Student Council representatives to lead weekly Morning Meetings with their classmates. We worked with them on asking questions, gathering ideas, listening to different perspectives, and communicating back to the students they represented.

Over time, we noticed a difference. Representatives began bringing more ideas from their classrooms into our meetings, and students reported knowing more about what the Student Council was discussing.

It wasn’t perfect, and I wouldn’t claim that every child suddenly felt represented. But the council was becoming more connected to the students it was meant to serve.

And I was learning something about my own expectations of leadership along the way.

Representation Isn’t the Same as Participation

I’ve thought about that experience quite a bit since leaving Lagos.

Now, as a deputy principal at Luanda International School, I’m helping establish our Primary Student Council. And one thing I want to be careful about is not treating those 21 students as though they are the voice of the entire Primary School.

They’re not. Nor should we expect them to be.

They are a vehicle for student voice. One of several ways we can understand what children think and experience.

That’s an important distinction for me.

I want our representatives to feel proud of their leadership roles, but I also want them to understand that leadership involves making space for other people. Sometimes that means asking a question rather than offering an opinion. Sometimes it means bringing forward an idea they don’t personally agree with because it’s important to their classmates.

And sometimes it means recognising that the students who don’t volunteer for leadership positions still have just as much of a stake in what happens at school.

I think we can unintentionally place too much weight on formal student leadership structures. We establish a council, elect representatives, and feel reassured that students have a voice.

But having a Student Council doesn’t tell us whether children feel heard.

We have to find that out.

What Students Notice

One of the things that surprised me most about the experience in Lagos was that students outside the Student Council were paying attention to how it worked.

They noticed that their ideas weren’t necessarily making it into the conversation. They noticed the gap between having representatives and feeling represented.

I hadn’t noticed that gap in quite the same way.

And I think that’s worth considering as school leaders.

We spend a lot of time looking at school through an adult lens. We review data, evaluate programmes, develop schedules, and discuss what’s working. All of that is important.

But children experience the decisions we make differently.

They notice things we might overlook, particularly when it comes to how included they feel, how decisions affect their daily lives, and whether the opportunities we create are meaningful to them.

Of course, students don’t always have the full picture. There are reasons we make certain decisions that children may not understand, and there are times when we have to say no.

But I don’t think that makes their perspectives any less useful.

Sometimes their feedback might simply confirm something we already suspected. Other times, as happened with our Student Council, it might challenge an assumption we didn’t even realise we were making.

A Question of Mission Integrity

The LYIS Leadership Framework asks leaders to consider how their school’s purpose and values are reflected in everyday decisions. It also speaks about managing the right change at the right time.

For me, the experience at AISL connects to both.

We wanted students to have agency and opportunities to contribute to their school community. We’d created a Student Council with those intentions in mind.

But when students told us they didn’t feel represented, we had a choice. We could continue with the structure we’d created, or we could reconsider whether it was doing what we’d intended.

We chose to make some changes.

They weren’t particularly complicated changes, either. We didn’t create another committee or introduce a new programme. We adjusted expectations and spent more time teaching children how to involve their peers.

Looking back, I think that was the right response because the problem wasn’t that we lacked opportunities for student leadership. It was that we hadn’t thought carefully enough about what those opportunities required of the students participating in them.

This is something I continue to think about in my leadership role.

When we’re trying to improve something at school, it’s easy to focus on the structure or the process. But I think we also need to ask whether the people we’re trying to serve are experiencing it in the way we intended.

And if they’re not, we should be prepared to reconsider our approach.

What I’m Taking Forward

As we develop the Student Council at LIS, I want our representatives to learn that leadership isn’t about being the person with all the ideas.

It’s about helping other people’s ideas become part of the conversation.

I also want to make sure we’re not relying on the Student Council alone to tell us what children think. We need to listen to students in classrooms, on the playground, during informal conversations, and in other spaces where they feel comfortable sharing their experiences.

Some children will happily speak in front of a group. Others won’t. That doesn’t make their perspectives any less important.

I still find it interesting that my first reaction to those students in Lagos was to wonder why they hadn’t put themselves forward.

At the time, I was placing the responsibility on them to participate in something we’d created. It took their feedback for me to think more carefully about our responsibility to ensure that the structure was working for them.

I don’t think I’ll forget that.

We ask students to reflect on their learning, listen to feedback, and reconsider their approach when something isn’t working. I think we should be prepared to do the same.

And perhaps that’s one of the simplest ways to think about mission integrity. Not whether we’ve created structures that reflect our values on paper, but whether we’re willing to question those structures when students tell us their experiences don’t match our intentions.

Rachel Cannon, Primary Deputy Principal, Luanda International School, Angola

LYIS is proud to partner with Beyond Classrooms

Worth sharing? Pass it on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Lead alongside the people who write here.

Lead alongside people who get it.

Membership from £95 a year. Mentoring, member pricing on courses, first call on conference places, and a community that has your back.

The Principal’s Blog, in your inbox

A new article from an international school leader most weeks, plus news of events and courses.

Those we work with

  • Accessit by Follett Software
  • Beyond Classrooms
  • Raising Futures Kenya
  • Sisi
Become a member