For people who aspire to lead international schools

Principal’s Blog

When Children Are Trusted to Lead

by Nicholas Bevington

It is easy to dismiss pupil voice as glorious ideas that are rarely deliverable. I have come to believe that this is a failure of structure, not of children. Give children the right architecture and they do not just dream up doughnuts and longer breaks. They organise, they influence and they change how a school runs.

The Caricature We Have Learned to Expect

Ask a group of children what they would change about school and you can usually predict the answer. When I asked a conference audience of school leaders to share the requests their own pupils had made, the same wish lists came up that I have often heard from my own cohorts. Doughnuts at break. Chocolate fountains in the dining hall. Longer breaks and no homework at all. Films every afternoon, an escalator instead of the stairs, and, my own favourite, a school zebra.

We smile, because we have heard it all before, and somewhere in that smile a quiet conclusion forms: that pupil voice, however well meant, rarely rises above the impractical. It is a comfortable conclusion, because it lets us off the hook. If children only ever ask for the fanciful, then consulting them becomes a courtesy rather than a responsibility. But I have come to think the caricature tells us far less about children than it does about the structures we place them in.

A Failure of Structure, Not of Children

At our school we have built one of the more developed junior school leadership programmes I know of, and watching it work has changed how I think about pupil voice. The quality of what children offer depends almost entirely on the structure we give them to offer it in. Change the structure and the ideas change with it.

You can see this even in the elections. When our children campaign to be Head Students, the better manifestos are strikingly realistic, setting out workable proposals mapped onto the school’s values, with only the occasional indulgence tucked in brackets alongside. A good structure does not stifle the imagination. It draws out the part of it that can actually be built.

Our own structure runs deep. Elected Head Students sit at the top, with House Captains elected by their Houses and elected class representatives forming a Student Council, alongside a wide family of appointed ambassador groups covering sport, reading, sustainability, music, the arts, compassion and global community. Over 90% of our children apply for a role each year, and we aim for every child who wants one to hold a position at least once before they leave us. The point is not the organogram. It is that the structure is real enough, and permanent enough, for children’s better ideas to take hold rather than evaporate.

What Children Actually Ran

The case does not rest on a single campaign. Last year, counting only what was genuinely delivered, our ambassador groups ran more than seventy student-led activities, led over twenty assemblies themselves, drove fifteen or so lasting changes to how the school operates and built more than ten partnerships beyond our gates.

The detail is more persuasive than the totals. Our Sports Ambassadors organised House games of their own, such as House Capture the Flag and House Yoshi. Library Ambassadors set up a book swap and lunchtime sessions they called Reading in the Sun. Music Ambassadors put on weekly Promenade concerts, an Open Mic and a Guess the Song competition. Sustainability Ambassadors delivered No Carbon November and, after gathering the evidence themselves, cut food waste by over 50% and persuaded the school to switch to more sustainable glue sticks. Compassion Ambassadors built a Kindness Kiosk from nothing. Mandarin Ambassadors led translation initiatives, literacy ambassadors set up pen-pal links with other schools, and Community Ambassadors forged an ongoing friendship with a local care home.

None of this was set as a task by a teacher. The common assumption is that student leaders help adults run things. What I have watched is closer to the reverse. The children had the ideas and did the organising. Our role was to build the conditions and then step back.

Leading without Any Power at All

What strikes me most is that none of these groups held any formal power. An ambassador cannot compel a single person to do anything. Everything they achieved, they achieved by influence: through assemblies, videos, posters and, most of all, by example and the quiet persuasion of their peers.

This is worth dwelling on, because it is arguably the purest form of leadership there is. We tend to associate leadership with position, with the badge that lets someone issue instructions. These children had none of that. When the Kindness Kiosk changed how pupils treated one another, it happened because other children chose to follow, not because they were told to. I am not sure there is a better teacher of what leadership actually asks of a person than having to move a room without any authority to fall back on.

Teaching Democracy by Practising It

There is a democratic thread running through this that schools too often overlook. Our elected roles are chosen using the Single Transferable Vote. Children rank the candidates in order of preference, the candidate with the fewest votes drops out each round, and if your first choice is eliminated, your vote transfers to your next. The effect is that a candidate cannot win on the enthusiasm of a narrow group. To succeed, they have to reach across the whole electorate and earn the second and third preferences of children who did not put them first. That is precisely the habit of mind we want in a leader, and they learn it by doing it.

The balance between elected and appointed roles is just as deliberate. Election teaches campaigning and persuasion. Appointment, handled on a Leadership Day after children have shown what they can do, lets us notice the quieter potential an election would overlook. We also ask children to apply for these roles themselves, at school, rather than through applications written at home. The leadership is theirs to seek, not their parents’ to arrange on their behalf.

What the Evidence Suggests

The research here is encouraging rather than conclusive, and it points consistently in one direction. Dana Mitra’s study of student voice initiatives found that giving young people a genuine role in school decisions was associated with growth in three assets central to youth development: agency, belonging and competence. Those are precisely the qualities our ambassadors develop, and every one of our groups reported real gains in confidence, communication and public speaking.

On belonging, the strongest evidence comes from a meta-analysis by Korpershoek and colleagues of eighty-two studies. It found that a stronger sense of school belonging was positively associated with academic achievement, though the correlation there was small, and more strongly with motivation, engagement and self-efficacy, alongside lower rates of absence and dropout. The relationships are correlational rather than causal and should not be overstated. Even so, they make a reasonable case that belonging is not a soft addition to the real work of school but part of the foundation the rest is built on, and leadership that gives children a genuine stake in their community is among the surer ways to strengthen it.

From Representation to Contribution

If there is one shift I would ask fellow school leaders to consider, it is this. Much of what we call pupil voice is really representation: children are consulted, their views are noted, and the adults decide. That has its place, but it is a comparatively modest ambition. The richer prize is contribution, where children are not only heard but trusted to make things happen, and then held to the standard that trust implies.

The case for it reaches well beyond school. The habits these children are building, organising a project, carrying people with them, judging what will work and recovering when it does not, are the habits of effective adults, and they are far easier to acquire at ten than at thirty. There is a subtler gain too. A child who has tried to run something learns, as no lecture could teach them, the difference between a good idea and a deliverable one. They come to see why the school zebra flounders and the book swap succeeds. That judgment does not quieten their voice. It focuses it, because a proposal shaped by someone who understands what delivery demands is a proposal worth listening to.

When we manage all of this, the doughnuts do not disappear entirely, and nor should they. They simply take their place beside book swaps that ran, concerts that happened, a care home befriended and a school culture noticeably changed, all of it the work of children we chose to trust. That, in the end, is the case for taking pupil voice seriously. So children can tell us what they want, and show us what they can do.

References: 

Korpershoek, H., Canrinus, E. T., Fokkens-Bruinsma, M. and de Boer, H. (2020) ‘The relationships between school belonging and students’ motivational, social-emotional, behavioural, and academic outcomes in secondary education: a meta-analytic review’, Research Papers in Education, 35(6), pp. 641-680 (first published online in 2019). Mitra, D. L. (2004) ‘The Significance of Students: Can Increasing “Student Voice” in Schools Lead to Gains in Youth Development?’, Teachers College Record, 106(4), pp. 651-688.

Nicholas Bevington, Head of Junior School, Dulwich College (Singapore)

LYIS is proud to partner with Beyond Classrooms

Worth sharing? Pass it on.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Lead alongside the people who write here.

Lead alongside people who get it.

Membership from £95 a year. Mentoring, member pricing on courses, first call on conference places, and a community that has your back.

The Principal’s Blog, in your inbox

A new article from an international school leader most weeks, plus news of events and courses.

Those we work with

  • Accessit by Follett Software
  • Beyond Classrooms
  • Raising Futures Kenya
  • Sisi
  • WildChina Education
  • Totally Teach
Become a member